The hype begins Sunday afternoon, a full day before the Manning brothers hit television screens nationwide. Peyton Manning's phone buzzes with a barrage of voice memos from her younger brother, Eli. These are not chance encounters; they are strategic dispatches full of pre-match analysis.
“Peyton, the RPOs seemed harsh,” one memo states. Another notes: “Kirk just took a shot under center. Strange, right?”
This unique preparation routine came about a few years earlier. During a Broncos game, a late call from a coach forced Peyton into the stadium bathroom for a clandestine conversation. Scribbling notes on a flimsy notepad has proven impractical, leading to the adoption of voice memos, a more efficient way to exchange information. Now, this auditory exchange forms the backbone of their preparation for a broadcast that will captivate over a million viewers.
This week, the brothers break down every detail of the upcoming Eagles-Falcons matchup, including the intricacies of the Eagles' “Tush Push” play. They discuss quarterback Kirk Cousins' use of the silent count at home, with Peyton drawing parallels to his early playoff experiences and the psychological impact of such a tactic.
For the fourth consecutive year, “ManningCast” offers an alternative experience to “Monday Night Football.” It's a blend of sibling camaraderie, expert analysis, and celebrity appearances, all orchestrated from the comfort of Eli's New Jersey basement and Peyton's converted garage studio in Denver. The Athletic was granted exclusive access, witnessing the entire process unfold, from the initial voice memos to the live broadcast.
Both brothers approach broadcasting with a gamer's mentality. Peyton, always a movie buff, still uses his worn spiral notebooks. He relies on Eli, just as he once relied on his backup quarterbacks, to provide additional breakdowns of the film. Meanwhile, Eli balances his broadcast duties with family time, playing soccer and ball with his children before settling into his basement studio.
Miles away, the brothers prepare for the broadcast. Peyton arrives at her friend's garage unassumingly, walking past a collection of classic cars to reach her designated spot. Both are wearing their game uniforms: khakis and quarter-zips. As the broadcast begins, a familiar face appears on the screen: Bill Belichick, the legendary coach and longtime rival of the Mannings. His presence adds a layer of unexpected camaraderie and insightful commentary.
The “ManningCast” was born out of Peyton's desire for a different kind of television role. He turned down lucrative offers from major networks, seeking a balance between his passion for football and his family life. Coaching had little appeal, and Eli shared his brother's aversion to the traditional analyst role. The solution emerged in the form of Omaha Productions, Peyton's media company. Co-founder Jamie Horowitz envisioned a casual, conversational format, allowing siblings to interact as they would while watching a game at home.
The show's success led to a long-term extension with ESPN, solidifying its status as an innovative alternative broadcast. Initial plans for a host were shelved after a test revealed the brothers' natural chemistry and ability to carry the show on their own.
On game day, a dedicated team transforms Eli's basement and Peyton's borrowed garage into functional studios. The brothers' contrasting personalities emerge throughout the broadcast. Peyton's intensity and attention to detail are balanced by Eli's laid-back demeanor and dry humor. While guest appearances add variety, the core of the show remains the brothers' in-depth analysis and playful banter. Their genuine enthusiasm for the game is palpable, even after retirement.
The “ManningCast” is more than just an alternative broadcast; it is a testament to the enduring power of the brotherly bond and shared passion for football. It reminds us that even in retirement, the competitive fire and love of the game can burn brightly. And it all starts with some voice memos.
